regex - Does javascript regexp (|) pipe operator works same as the (||) logical operator? - Stack Overflow

admin管理员组

文章数量:1350348

I know that the regexp OR (|) operator in javascript matches if one of the sub-strings on both sides of the regexp is matched.

I also know that in JavaScript the logical (||) OR operator checks the second operand only if the first operand is false.

So I want to know if the regexp (|) (also called pipe) OR operator works the same way or it first matches both the sub-strings and then decide the match. If I am not wrong I think it should check the second right hand sub-string only when left hand sub-string is not matched for the sake of performance.

I know that the regexp OR (|) operator in javascript matches if one of the sub-strings on both sides of the regexp is matched.

I also know that in JavaScript the logical (||) OR operator checks the second operand only if the first operand is false.

So I want to know if the regexp (|) (also called pipe) OR operator works the same way or it first matches both the sub-strings and then decide the match. If I am not wrong I think it should check the second right hand sub-string only when left hand sub-string is not matched for the sake of performance.

• javascript
• regex
• logical-operators

Share Improve this question Follow asked Nov 26, 2012 at 6:39 me_digvijayme_digvijay 5,5021010 gold badges5151 silver badges8686 bronze badges 2

• I'm sure it works in a similar fashion...it's called short-circuiting by the way. Is there any specific reason you want to know? Or is this just a general question? – Ian Commented Nov 26, 2012 at 6:46
• @Ian: I was working with the javascript regexp and when I encountered the OR operator, I thought that with logical operators its very simple to implement the so called short-circuiting, but with regexp, I think there must be some performance or memory cost to implement the same. – me_digvijay Commented Nov 26, 2012 at 6:50

Add a ment  | 

1 Answer 1

Sorted by: Reset to default 8

Yes, | in regular expressions is short circuiting.

For example,

"The | is short circuiting, NOT!".match(/The \| is short circuiting(?:|, NOT!)/)

produces

["The | is short circuiting"]

while

"The | is not short circuiting, NOT!".match(/The \| is not short circuiting(?:, NOT!|)/)

produces

["The | is not short circuiting, NOT!"]

The language specification says

The production Disjunction :: Alternative | Disjunction evaluates as follows:

1. Evaluate Alternative to obtain a Matcher m1.
2. Evaluate Disjunction to obtain a Matcher m2.
3. Return an internal Matcher closure that takes two arguments, a State x and a Continuation c, and performs the following:

   a. Call m1(x, c) and let r be its result.
   b. If r isn't failure, return r.
   c. Call m2(x, c) and return its result.

15.10.2.3 line 3b is where the short-circuiting is specified.

本文标签： regexDoes javascript regexp () pipe operator works same as the () logical operatorStack Overflow