admin管理员组

文章数量:1129454

I am trying to dynamically render components based on their type.

For example:

var type = "Example";
var ComponentName = type + "Component";
return <ComponentName />; 
// Returns <examplecomponent />  instead of <ExampleComponent />

I tried the solution proposed here React/JSX dynamic component names

That gave me an error when compiling (using browserify for gulp). It expected XML where I was using an array syntax.

I could solve this by creating a method for every component:

newExampleComponent() {
    return <ExampleComponent />;
}

newComponent(type) {
    return this["new" + type + "Component"]();
}

But that would mean a new method for every component I create. There must be a more elegant solution to this problem.

I am very open to suggestions.

EDIT: As pointed out by gmfvpereira these days there is an official documentation entry for this: .html#choosing-the-type-at-runtime

I am trying to dynamically render components based on their type.

For example:

var type = "Example";
var ComponentName = type + "Component";
return <ComponentName />; 
// Returns <examplecomponent />  instead of <ExampleComponent />

I tried the solution proposed here React/JSX dynamic component names

That gave me an error when compiling (using browserify for gulp). It expected XML where I was using an array syntax.

I could solve this by creating a method for every component:

newExampleComponent() {
    return <ExampleComponent />;
}

newComponent(type) {
    return this["new" + type + "Component"]();
}

But that would mean a new method for every component I create. There must be a more elegant solution to this problem.

I am very open to suggestions.

EDIT: As pointed out by gmfvpereira these days there is an official documentation entry for this: https://reactjs.org/docs/jsx-in-depth.html#choosing-the-type-at-runtime

• javascript
• reactjs

Share Improve this question Follow edited Dec 12, 2022 at 12:25 Sam asked Apr 26, 2015 at 9:23 SamSam 4,39522 gold badges1919 silver badges1313 bronze badges

Add a comment  | 

17 Answers 17

Sorted by: Reset to default 291

<MyComponent /> compiles to React.createElement(MyComponent, {}), which expects a string (HTML tag) or a function (ReactClass) as first parameter.

You could just store your component class in a variable with a name that starts with an uppercase letter. See HTML tags vs React Components.

var MyComponent = Components[type + "Component"];
return <MyComponent />;

compiles to

var MyComponent = Components[type + "Component"];
return React.createElement(MyComponent, {});

There is an official documentation about how to handle such situations is available here: https://facebook.github.io/react/docs/jsx-in-depth.html#choosing-the-type-at-runtime

Basically it says:

Wrong:

import React from 'react';
import { PhotoStory, VideoStory } from './stories';

const components = {
    photo: PhotoStory,
    video: VideoStory
};

function Story(props) {
    // Wrong! JSX type can't be an expression.
    return <components[props.storyType] story={props.story} />;
}

Correct:

import React from 'react';
import { PhotoStory, VideoStory } from './stories';

const components = {
    photo: PhotoStory,
    video: VideoStory
};

function Story(props) {
    // Correct! JSX type can be a capitalized variable.
    const SpecificStory = components[props.storyType];
    return <SpecificStory story={props.story} />;
}

There should be a container that maps component names to all components that are supposed to be used dynamically. Component classes should be registered in a container because in modular environment there's otherwise no single place where they could be accessed. Component classes cannot be identified by their names without specifying them explicitly because function name is minified in production.

Component map

It can be plain object:

class Foo extends React.Component { ... }
...
const componentsMap = { Foo, Bar };
...
const componentName = 'Fo' + 'o';
const DynamicComponent = componentsMap[componentName];
<DynamicComponent/>;

Or Map instance:

const componentsMap = new Map([[Foo, Foo], [Bar, Bar]]);
...
const DynamicComponent = componentsMap.get(componentName);

Plain object is more suitable because it benefits from property shorthand.

Barrel module

A barrel module with named exports can act as such map:

// Foo.js
export class Foo extends React.Component { ... }

// dynamic-components.js
export * from './Foo';
export * from './Bar';

// some module that uses dynamic component
import * as componentsMap from './dynamic-components';

const componentName = 'Fo' + 'o';
const DynamicComponent = componentsMap[componentName];
<DynamicComponent/>;

This works well with one class per module code style.

Decorator

Decorators can be used with class components for syntactic sugar, this still requires to specify class names explicitly and register them in a map:

const componentsMap = {};

function dynamic(Component) {
  if (!Component.displayName)
    throw new Error('no name');

  componentsMap[Component.displayName] = Component;

  return Component;
}

...

@dynamic
class Foo extends React.Component {
  static displayName = 'Foo'
  ...
}

A decorator can be used as higher-order component with functional components:

const Bar = props => ...;
Bar.displayName = 'Bar';

export default dynamic(Bar);

The use of non-standard displayName instead of random property also benefits debugging.

With the introduction of React.lazy, we can now use a true dynamic approach to import the component and render it.

import React, { lazy, Suspense } from 'react';

const App = ({ componentName, ...props }) => {
  const DynamicComponent = lazy(() => import(`./${componentName}`));
    
  return (
    <Suspense fallback={<div>Loading...</div>}>
      <DynamicComponent {...props} />
    </Suspense>
  );
};

This approach makes some assumptions about the file hierarchy of course and can make the code easy to break.

Across all options with component maps I haven't found the simplest way to define the map using ES6 short syntax:

import React from 'react'
import { PhotoStory, VideoStory } from './stories'

const components = {
    PhotoStory,
    VideoStory,
}

function Story(props) {
    //given that props.story contains 'PhotoStory' or 'VideoStory'
    const SpecificStory = components[props.story]
    return <SpecificStory/>
}

For a wrapper component, a simple solution would be to just use React.createElement directly (using ES6).

import RaisedButton from 'mui/RaisedButton'
import FlatButton from 'mui/FlatButton'
import IconButton from 'mui/IconButton'

class Button extends React.Component {
  render() {
    const { type, ...props } = this.props

    let button = null
    switch (type) {
      case 'flat': button = FlatButton
      break
      case 'icon': button = IconButton
      break
      default: button = RaisedButton
      break
    }

    return (
      React.createElement(button, { ...props, disableTouchRipple: true, disableFocusRipple: true })
    )
  }
}

I figured out a new solution. Do note that I am using ES6 modules so I am requiring the class. You could also define a new React class instead.

var components = {
    example: React.createFactory( require('./ExampleComponent') )
};

var type = "example";

newComponent() {
    return components[type]({ attribute: "value" });
}

If your components are global you can simply do:

var nameOfComponent = "SomeComponent";
React.createElement(window[nameOfComponent], {});

Having a map doesn't look good at all with a large amount of components. I'm actually surprised that no one has suggested something like this:

var componentName = "StringThatContainsComponentName";
const importedComponentModule = require("path/to/component/" + componentName).default;
return React.createElement(importedComponentModule); 

This one has really helped me when I needed to render a pretty large amount of components loaded in a form of json array.

Assume we have a flag, no different from the state or props:

import ComponentOne from './ComponentOne';
import ComponentTwo from './ComponentTwo';

~~~

const Compo = flag ? ComponentOne : ComponentTwo;

~~~

<Compo someProp={someValue} />

With flag Compo fill with one of ComponentOne or ComponentTwo and then the Compo can act like a React Component.

Assuming you are able to export * from components like so...

// src/components/index.js

export * from './Home'
export * from './Settings'
export * from './SiteList'

You can then re-import * into a new comps object, which can then be used to access your modules.

// src/components/DynamicLoader.js

import React from 'react'
import * as comps from 'components'

export default function ({component, defaultProps}) {
  const DynamicComponent = comps[component]

  return <DynamicComponent {...defaultProps} />
}

Just pass in a string value that identifies which component you want to paint, wherever you need to paint it.

<DynamicLoader component='Home' defaultProps={someProps} />

Suspose we wish to access various views with dynamic component loading.The following code gives a working example of how to accomplish this by using a string parsed from the search string of a url.

Lets assume we want to access a page 'snozberrys' with two unique views using these url paths:

'http://localhost:3000/snozberrys?aComponent'

and

'http://localhost:3000/snozberrys?bComponent'

we define our view's controller like this:

import React, { Component } from 'react';
import ReactDOM from 'react-dom'
import {
  BrowserRouter as Router,
  Route
} from 'react-router-dom'
import AComponent from './AComponent.js';
import CoBComponent sole from './BComponent.js';

const views = {
  aComponent: <AComponent />,
  console: <BComponent />
}

const View = (props) => {
  let name = props.location.search.substr(1);
  let view = views[name];
  if(view == null) throw "View '" + name + "' is undefined";
  return view;
}

class ViewManager extends Component {
  render() {
    return (
      <Router>
        <div>
          <Route path='/' component={View}/>
        </div>
      </Router>
    );
  }
}

export default ViewManager

ReactDOM.render(<ViewManager />, document.getElementById('root'));

本文标签： javascriptReactJSX Dynamic Component NameStack Overflow